Linux ext3 FAQ

Version: 2003-04-09 (see history)

Q: Where can I find this FAQ?

Currently at: http://batleth.sapienti-sat.org/projects/FAQs/ext3-faq.html.
If you have any comments or suggestions just let me know: Juri Haberland <juri-at-koschikode.com>

Q: What is ext3?

Ext3 is a journaling filesystem developed by Stephen Tweedie. It is compatible to ext2 filesystems; actually you can look at it as an ext2 filesystem with a journal file. The journaling capability means no more waiting for fsck's or worrying about metadata corruption. What is most noticeable is that you can switch back and forth between ext2 and ext3 on a partition without any problem: it is just a matter of giving the mount command the right filesystem type.

Q: Is there a mailing list or mailing list archive?

The ext3-user mailing list is at https://listman.redhat.com/mailman/listinfo/ext3-users/.
An archive can be found at https://listman.redhat.com/pipermail/ext3-users/ and a searchable one at http://marc.theaimsgroup.com/?l=ext3-users.

Q: Where can I get ext3 for linux?

From kernel version 2.4.15 on (don't use this one!) ext3 is included in the standard kernel so you don't need any extra patch. Patches against older 2.4 kernels as well as intermediate patches can be found at http://www.zip.com.au/~akpm/linux/ext3/. You can get the old ext3 patches for kernel 2.2 either from your favourite kernel mirror ftp://ftp.*.kernel.org/pub/linux/kernel/people/sct/ext3/ or from ftp://ftp.uk.linux.org/pub/linux/sct/fs/jfs/.
As of writing this FAQ the most recent version for kernel 2.2 is 0.0.7a which is rather outdated. There is no development going into ext3 for 2.2 anymore.

Q: What do I need to build an ext3 ready kernel?

From 2.4.16 on you just need a fresh kernel tarball. The following description is for kernel version 2.2, but should work in the same way for older 2.4 kernels that don't have ext3 support. You need a fresh kernel tarball and the ext3 patches:

cd /usr/src
wget ftp://ftp.*.kernel.org/pub/linux/kernel/v2.2/linux-2.2.20.tar.bz2
wget ftp://ftp.*.kernel.org/pub/linux/kernel/people/sct/ext3/ext3-0.0.7a.tar.bz2
rm -rf linux
tar -xjvf linux-2.2.20.tar.bz2
tar -xjvf ext3-0.0.7a.tar.bz2
cd linux
cat ../ext3-0.0.7a/linux-2.2.19.kdb.diff | patch -sp1
cat ../ext3-0.0.7a/linux-2.2.19.ext3.diff | patch -sp1

You will get a failed hunk in the main Makefile because of a mismatch in the kernel sublevel version. You can ignore it safely.

After this you must configure your kernel with make [menu]config and set CONFIG_EXPERIMENTAL=y. Then you can set CONFIG_EXT3_FS=y and build a new kernel.

You also need a recent (at least version 1.25) e2fsprogs package with ext3 support, which you can download from ftp://download.sourceforge.net/pub/sourceforge/e2fsprogs/.

Q: How do I convert my ext2 partition to ext3? (was: How do I use ext3?)

Before you can mount a partition as ext3 you have to create a journal on it. The easiest way to do it is to type:

    tune2fs -j /dev/hdaX

This can be done on an unmounted or on a mounted filesystem. If you create the journal on a mounted filesystem you will see a .journal file. Don't try to delete this and don't back this up or restore it from backup! If you run tune2fs -j on an unmounted partition an unvisible journal file will be created.
Now you can mount the filesystem as ext3 using:

    mount -t ext3 /dev/hdaX /mnt/somewhere

With mke2fs -j /dev/hdaX you can format a partition as ext3 (as always it will be also usable as ext2 partion).

Q: How can I recover (undelete) deleted files from my ext3 partition?

Actually, you can't! This is what one of the developers, Andreas Dilger, said about it:

In order to ensure that ext3 can safely resume an unlink after a crash, it actually zeros out the block pointers in the inode, whereas
ext2 just marks these blocks as unused in the block bitmaps and marks the inode as "deleted" and leaves the block pointers alone.

Your only hope is to "grep" for parts of your files that have been deleted and hope for the best.

Q: 'df' command says partition is full, while 'du' reports free space

Theodore Ts'o, the ext2 developer, said:

The standard cause for this is some user process keeping a deleted file open. When this happens, the space is not visible via 'du', since the file is no longer visible in the directory tree. However, the space is still used by the file until it is deallocated, and that can only happen once the last process which has the file open either closes its file descriptor to the file, or the process exits. You can use the lsof program to try to find which process is keeping an open file. Usually it's some log file, or some large data base file which gets rotated out, but some older process are still keeping the log file open.

Q: I compiled ext3 as a module and my / partition gets mounted as ext2

(This part was initally suggested by Boris Wesslowski; major overhaul by Theodore Ts'o)

If you have ext2 compiled into the kernel and ext3 as a module and your root filesystem is ext2/3, then the kernel will always mount the root fs as ext2 and not as ext3 since at the time when the root filesystem is mounted, the kernel does not have access to the modules, since they are located on the root filesystem. (This is a chicken and egg problem!)
If you have this setup, you might first want to consider whether it makes sense to compile ext3 as a module. If you want to use ext3 on your root filesystem, the ext3 filesystem module will always be loaded and can not be unloaded, so it might as well be compiled-in. Furthermore, modules waste a tiny amount of memory (on average 2k per module), and take up an extra entry in the TLB cache --- a slight, and perhaps not measurable disadvantage, but given that there is no real advantage to compiling ext3 as a module, why bother?
If you do want to compile ext3 as a module and use it as your root filesystem, it can be done, but what you must do is do is boot into an initial ramdisk (initrd) image as your root image. This initrd image will contain the necessary modules (scsi, ext3, etc.) so you can mount your "real" root filesystem and then use pivot_root to replace the initrd root filesystem with the "real" root filesystem.
Most distributions do the pivot_root trick automatically, but they differ in how the tool which builds the initrd image needs to be called.

On a SuSE system you have to put "jbd ext3" (in this order!) into the YaST setting INITRD_MODULES. Then do a mk_initrd and it should work.
On a Red Hat system it seems that it is sufficiant to just do a mkinitrd.
On a Debian system (woody and above) you must run the command:
mkinitrd -o boot/initrd.img-2.4.18-386 /lib/modules/2.4.18-386
where 2.4.18-386 must be substituted with the version number of the debian kernel which you are currently using. Note: this requires that you have the initrd-tools package installed, and if you currently are not using an initrd setup, your lilo or grub configuration files must be modified to tell the booting kernel to use the initrd image.

Q: How do I convert my ext3 partition back to ext2?

Actually there is only little need to do so, because in most cases it is sufficient to mount the partition explicitely as ext2. But if you really need to convert your partion back to ext2 just do the following on an unmounted partition:

    tune2fs -O ^has_journal /dev/hdaX

To be on the safe side you should force a fsck run on this partition afterwards:

    fsck.ext2 -f /dev/hdaX

After this procedure you can safely delete the .journal file if there was any.

Q: How do I convert the journal file from version 1 to version 2?

Just type:

    mount /dev/hdaX /mnt -o journal=update

to convert your old (ext3 v0.0.3* and earlier) filesystem to the new journal format.

Q: How do I convert my root filesystem from version 1 to version 2?

Just issue a "lilo -R linux rw rootflags=journal=update" and reboot.

Q: I updated ext3 today. Got all of my mounts converted. Now on boot, I see: "EXT3-fs: mounted filesystem with ordered data mode". Is this normal?

Nigel Metheringham answered this on the ext3-users mailing list as follows:

That's fine. The EXT3-fs message is just telling you it mounted the fs OK. It's also telling you what form of journaling you are using.

ext3 has 2 formats of journal:

version 1 - default and only possibility for ext3 releases 0.0.3* and earlier
version 2 - default for filesystems created with 0.0.4 and later

Version 2 journals support additional semantics required to allow metadata journaling, and provide 2 new forms of journaling - ordered and writeback. Both V1 & V2 journals support data journaling (where everything that would go to disk is journaled).

The CHANGES file in the distribution says this:

New mount options:

    "mount -o journal=update"
        Mounts a filesystem with a Version 1 journal, upgrading the
        journal dynamically to Version 2.

    "mount -o data=journal"
        Journals all data and metadata, so data is written twice. This
        is the mode which all prior versions of ext3 used.

    "mount -o data=ordered"
        Only journals metadata changes, but data updates are flushed to
        disk before any transactions commit. Data writes are not atomic
        but this mode still guarantees that after a crash, files will
        never contain stale data blocks from old files.

    "mount -o data=writeback"
        Only journals metadata changes, and data updates are entirely
        left to the normal "sync" process. After a crash, files will
        may contain stale data blocks from old files: this mode is
        exactly equivalent to running ext2 with a very fast fsck on reboot.

Ordered and Writeback data modes require a Version 2 journal: if you do
not update the journal format then only the Journaled data will be
allowed.

The default data mode is Journaled for a V1 journal, and Ordered for V2.

For more information also see RedHat's release notes from their 7.2 release.

Q: How stable is ext3?

In my experience it is as stable as ext2.

Q: Do quotas work on ext3?

Should do so with 2.4ish kernels. I had problems with 2.2 but others didn't...

Q: Does LILO work with ext3?

Yes.

History:

2003-04-09 - added new point about df/du; suggested by Theodore Ts'o

2003-01-24 - added new item about undeletion

2002-07-23 - enhanced 'using ext3 as a module' [thanks for the contributions!]

2002-04-02 - added new point about using ext3 as a module

2002-03-04 - added history ;)
           - minor corrections
	   - added a link to the RedHat 7.2 release notes